Tag Archives: media trackers

TV Commercial Hits Broward Commissioner Dale Holness On Phony Residency Claims

1 Reply

A clever new commercial from State Senator Chris Smith hits controversial Broward County Commissioner Dale V.C. Holness on his phony residency claims. Both men are seeking the District 9 seat on the Broward County Commission. Three years ago, this reporter exposed Holness’ false claims to reside in the district he represents. The evidence showed Holness lived outside the district he represents, though Article II, Section 2.01 A(3) of the Broward County Charter clearly states each commissioner “must be a resident of the particular district upon election.”

Holness claimed he lived in a run-down Lauderhill townhouse near the Florida Turnpike.

In May 2013, records from the Broward County Supervisor of Elections (SOE), stated Holness was registered to vote within District 9 by claiming to live in a small, older 940-square foot townhome in the Royal Oaks townhome development at 2630 N.W. 52nd Avenue in Lauderhill. Property records from the Broward County Property Appraiser (BCPA) show Holmes owns the small home but does not list it as his primary residence for his homestead tax exemption.

Property records listed the mailing address for Holness’ home as 4325 West Sunrise Blvd in Lauderhill. This is the business address for All Broward Realty, Inc., a company owned by Holness.

As Media Trackers Florida reported, the 2006 Central Lauderhill Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) master plan shows Lauderhill officials targeted the Royal Oaks for a dramatic makeover funded by federal and state grants. The plan says Royal Oaks is in “disrepair and in need of landscaping upkeep.” The entire neighborhood was part of an ambitious plan to build parks and improve roads and sewers. The Royal Oaks neighborhood was “identified as properties suitable for acquisition, demolition and redevelopment[.]”

As vice mayor of Lauderhill in 2006, Holness wrote the Central Lauderhill CRA master plan. Florida Department of State records show Holness has been an official of the Royal Oaks Condominium Association since 2000.

One month after our story, Bob Norman of Local 10 News visited Holness’ townhouse. Norman described the unit as, “A small run-down housing unit in Lauderhill stacked to the ceiling with furniture and boxes. A realtor’s locked box hangs from the door knob. The refrigerator isn’t plugged in and its door is wide open.”

“Nobody lives there,” said Herbert Fray, a handyman who tends the yards there.

Seeking answers, Bob Norman visited Holness at the Broward Government Center.

“Well, sir, we went to that home and there’s no way you live there. Do you live in your district?” asked Local 10 investigative reporter Bob Norman.

“I do,” Holness replied before leaving without answering any more questions.

Since those reports, Holness and his wife have moved to a home in the upscale Plantation neighborhood surrounding the Fort Lauderdale Country Club.

SMITH COMMERCIAL TAKES ON RESIDENCY

Chris Smith’s new ad takes on Holness’ residency issue by giving viewers a tour of all the places Smith has lived. Smith visits the homes he grew up in, the schools he attended and the home he currently lives in with his family. Smith points out that all of these homes are located in District 9.

FDLE Investigation Exposed Chip LaMarca Close Ties To Another Broward Health Commissioner

3 Replies

  The drama swirling around Broward Health is not the first time County Commissioner Chip LaMarca has been front and center in a Florida Department Of Law Enforcement (FDLE) investigation. According to numerous published reports, the FBI, FDLE and the Office of Inspector General (OIG) are looking into various contracts at Broward Health including a $71 million dollar deal with Zimmerman Advertising. Until last week, LaMarca was the vice president of community relations for Zimmerman Advertising.  As REDBROWARD reported yesterday, lawyers hired by Broward Health believed LaMarca to be the leading advocate for the massive multi-million dollar deal.

But in 2006, FDLE investigated Chip LaMarca’s role at a local electrical construction firm. The FDLE report exposes close ties between Chip LaMarca and the family of Broward Health Commissioner Maureen Spieker Canada.

On November 1, 2006, FDLE Special Agent Joseph Demma and Special Agent Supervisor Dan Cerione met with Robert Morgan, CEO of MGI Morgan General Mechanical Group and Wiliam Buckham of MWI Moving Water Industries to discuss “The unlawful and fraudulent use of Mr. Brown’s company name and Contractor License…by a former employee, Charles ‘Chip’ John LaMarca.” The FDLE agents were told LaMarca used Brown’s information to obtain notarized electrical permits from the City of Riviera Beach. Morgan provided a proposal document, on MGI letterehead, to Transparent Protection Systems. The proposal was signed by J. Charlie French of Transparent and LaMarca. When Morgan spoke with French, he told Morgan, “Mr. LaMarca stated to just write the check out to me, it will be cheaper for you.” French followed LaMarca’s instructions.

Morgan stated he fired LaMarca on September 20, 2006.

FDLE secured the assistance of the Broward State Attorney’s Office to further investigate the matter. The FDLE stated the investigated was based upon Morgan’s allegations of fraud, forgery, notary violation and possible official misconduct. In 2006, LaMarca was a City of Lighthouse Point commissioner.

On November 6, 2006, the Broward State Attorney’s Office issued two subpoenas for Chip LaMarca’s bank records. FDLE determined LaMarca paid for permits from Riviera Beach and Boca Raton with checks from his personal checking accounts. The Riviera Beach permit check was signed by LaMarca. The check for the Boca Raton permit was signed by his wife, Eileen LaMarca.

LAMARCA GOES ON THE OFFENSIVE

Following the review of personal and business banking records, FDLE decided to reach out to LaMarca’s current employers. On June 5, 2008, FDLE spoke with R.T. Armstrong, vice president of Kreg Electric, Inc. Armstrong stated LaMarca sells and installs generators. Armstrong said when the time comes to hook the generators to a transfer switch, “Kreg Electric applies for the appropriate permit and paperwork and a certified electrician completes the installation.” Armstrong had no complaints about LaMarca.

As the FDLE agent left Kreg Electric, LaMarca called the agent’s cellular telephone. LaMarca wanted to know why the FDLE was asking questions about him. LaMarca said his relationship with MGI had “deteriorated and as a result, employees of the company became bitter and provided information to the business community that was less than accurate. Mr. LaMarca attributed the situation to the failed business relationship.”

LAMARCA TALKS TO FDLE

Five days later, FDLE Special Agent James Futch interviewed Chip LaMarca. He described his role at MGI. He said he would arrange the sale and installation of residential and commercial generators. LaMarca said he was “not a licensed electrical contractor and as such could not acquire an electrical permit or conduct the electrical connections.”

LaMarca claimed his relationship with Morgan turned bitter over his compensation. He claimed Morgan owned him $72,000 he never paid. After he “pressed the issue” to avail, LaMarca claimed he quit to work for Kreg Electric, Inc. According to the FDLE report, “Mr. LaMarca indicated he considered the issue to be in the past and wanted nothing more to do with the situation.”

LaMarca denied forging signatures, denied improperly notarizing a document and stated he never worked a job under the MGI name without giving MGI monies owed them.

REPORT SHOWS LAMARCA TIES TO ANOTHER BROWARD HEALTH COMMISSIONER

More than one year later, the Broward State Attorney declined to bring charges in the matter. However, FDLE investigators discovered irregularities in a generator installation job in Lighthouse Point.

The investigators focused on generators installed at the Lighthouse home of Christian D. Spieker. Robert Morgan told special agents a generator and concrete slab had been installed at Spieker’s home. Morgan stated he had no record of the job and received no money. Morgan believed the installation would have a $12,000 price tag.

Morgan believed the Spieker installation may have been absorbed into a $250,000 installation at the Lighthouse Point marina. FDLE determined Spieker owned the marina. FDLE agents pulled the permit for the Spieker home installation.

Morgan stated the document contained his signature, but the job “was not submitted through MGI and he had no prior knowledge of this job’s existence. When presented with the permit for the Lighthouse Point Marina job, Morgan stated the signature was not his. Both permits were notarized by LaMarca.

According to State records, the Lighthouse Point Marina is owned and operated by Christian Spieker and his sister, Maureen Spieker Canada.  In 2014, Canada was appointed to the Broward Health Board of Commissioners. LaMarca was reference for Canada on her application for the position. In 2015, Chip LaMarca appointed Christian Spieker to the Broward Marine Advisory Committee.

CANADA RUNNING INTERFERENCE?

Last week, Canada urged fellow commissioners to delay naming a new board chair. The South Florida Sun-Sentinel quoted Canada attacking Florida Inspector General Melinda Miguel over Governor Rick Scott’s removal of David DiPietro and Darryl Wright from the board. Canada said, “If she disagrees with our decision as a board, that is not a basis for the suspension of the commissioners.”