Tag Archives: media trackers

Oakland Park Commission Candidate Scott Herman’s Odd Electoral Past

Scott Herman, right, and spouse all hugs with Charlie Crist

Scott Herman, right, and spouse all hugs with Charlie Crist

Perennial Republican-turned-Democrat candidate Scott Herman wants a seat on the City of Oakland Park Commission. A few years ago, Republican Scott Herman challenged Perry Thurston in a Florida House race. Then, Herman became a Democrat challenger to State Rep. George Moraitis of Fort Lauderdale. No matter the race, Herman’s campaigns are filled with oddities.

In August 2013, this reporter detailed Herman’s purchase of a bulletproof vest with campaign funds.

Campaign records filed with the Florida Division of Elections show the Herman campaign paid $538.06 for a “protective vest” from Federal Eastern International on May 7, 2013. The Herman campaign provided contradictory reasons for the questionable use of campaign funds.

The Herman campaign attacked the initial report of the purchase as a “cowardly approach to journalism.” Herman claimed the purchase was tied to an anonymous threat made on his campaign website in July of 2012. At the time, Herman was a Republican candidate challenging House Minority Leader Perry E. Thurston, Jr. for the District 93 seat.

In a press release the campaign said, “It is because of this threat, and the current hostility towards the LGBT Community that our campaign [has] taken a proactive approach by purchasing a bullet proof vest. This vest was imperative for the safety and welfare of a candidate. The purchase was additionally made with funds Scott Herman loaned to his own campaign, not at all using any donated funds.”

Before the statement was released, however, the Herman campaign gave a different rationale for the bulletproof vest purchase.

In an interview with the South Florida Sun-Sentinel, Herman campaign manager Tony Diaz said Herman bought the vest with personal funds because “he goes hunting and he bought it for personal safety.”

When advised that state records documented the purchase was made with campaign funds, “Diaz called Herman and called me back, this time explaining that the past threat prompted the purchase,” the Sun-Sentinel reported. “Diaz called back later to add that Herman said ‘because of the current climate that’s building more hostility toward gays, he wanted to be proactive.’”

The Herman campaign bristled at the news a former campaign aide also purchased a bulletproof vest with campaign funds. Just days after leaving the Herman campaign, Christopher Warnig announced his bid for a Broward County Commission seat. Even though he raised less than $500, Warnig listeda $255.44 expenditure for “protective apparel” purchased from NATMIL (National Military Armament, LLC). The Arkansas company specializes in small weapons and bulletproof vests.

The Herman campaign claims it fired Warnig after it learned Warnig had been arrested twice for impersonating a police officer. Warnig shot back with a lengthy press release attacking Herman’s Republican roots and support of the National Rifle Association (NRA).  Warnig claims he quit after he was “never rewarded for the long, exhausting hours he put into the Scott Herman Campaign.”

Warnig would later run for a spot on the Oakland Park commission.

During his campaign against Moraitis, Herman retained a Hooters waitress as an image consultant. On Herman’s official website, Natalee Toledo is listed as the campaign “image consultant.” Most candidates for state and local office do not list campaign staff, let alone “image consultants.”

However, the most damaging issue uncovered by this reporter dealt with Scott Herman’s political resume.

Scott Herman appears to be fudging his resume regarding his past political history in North Carolina.

Until moving to Broward County in 2009, Herman was a resident of Cabarrus county, North Carolina. According to his official campaign website, Herman held the elected office of  “Cabarrus County Board, Vice Chairman of the Board, At-Large.”

Just to the east of Charlotte, North Carolina, Cabarrus County is governed by a “five-member Board of Commissioners elected at large in countywide elections to serve staggered four-year terms.”

When asked if Herman had served on the Board of Commissioners, a Cabarrus County spokeperson told Media Trackers Florida, “No, [Herman] was never a commissioner.” The spokesperson said Herman had only served on the Cabarrus County Soil and Water Conservation District.  The spokesperson said the Cabarrus Soil and Water Conservation District is never referred to as the “County Board.”

The official minutes from the June 2003 meeting of the Cabarrus County Board of Commissioners state Scott Herman is “vice chairman of the Cabarrus Soil and Water Conservation District Supervisors.”

But in this August 2012 video interview with Broward County Republican Chairman Richard DeNapoli, Herman recounts his Cabarrus political resume. Herman said, “[I] ran for and became elected to the countywide seat there in Cabarrus county, which I ended up serving as vice chairman of that board.”

Last week, the South Florida Sun-Sentinel detailed the campaign funds Herman spent to explain his switch from the Republican party. The story, in which Herman is heavily quoted, mentions his previous career in North Carolina.

“Previously an elected member of the countywide Board of Supervisors in Cabarrus County, N.C., for four years, he moved to Broward in December 2009,” the Sun-Sentinel asserted.

In October 2012, a Sun-Sentinel story on Herman’s race against House Minority Leader Perry E. Thurston, Jr. (D-Fort Lauderdale) said “Herman has no Florida political experience, but he served a four-year term as an elected commissioner for Cabarrus County in North Carolina. He moved to Florida in 2009.”

Last week, Media Trackers Florida reported on the questions surrounding Herman’s purchase of a bulletproof with campaign funds. Campaign records filed with the Florida Division of Elections show the Herman campaign paid $538.06 for a “protective vest” from Federal Eastern International on May 7, 2013. The Herman campaign provided contradictory reasons for the questionable use of campaign funds.

The Herman campaign did not respond to requests for comment for this story.

Herman is running against Commissioner Michael Carn and Layne Walls.

Another Broward Democrat Wants To Represent District She Doesn’t Live In

Roxanne Y. Valies (via Twitter)

Roxanne Y. Valies (via Twitter)

Democrat Roxanne Y. Valies wants Broward voters to send her to Tallahassee to represent District 95 in the Florida House of Representatives. This largely minority district includes Lauderdale Lakes, Lauderhill and North Lauderdale. Just one small problem: according to numerous Federal, State and local records, Roxanne Y. Valies does not live in District 95.

The Florida Constitution requires all state legislators to live in the House or Senate district they represent. Since 2013, this reporter has exposed numerous politicians violating the residency requirement. These politicians included State Sen. Maria Sachs, Rep. Lori Berman, Rep. Perry Thurston, Rep. Jared Moskowitz, Rep. Alan Williams, and Hazelle Rogers, the current representative of District 95.

As first reported in April 2013, Rogers owns a large home with her husband outside the District she represents, but claims she is living  in a small, older condominium within her district.

In 2008, Rogers listed a Lauderdale Lakes house in District 94 as her official mailing address. The 2,184-square foot home is owned by Rogers and her husband, Clifton. Records from the Florida Division of Elections show the Rogers home is the current official address for Premier Group Enterprises, Inc. Documents filed on April 17, 2012 show Rogers and her husband are officers of the corporation.

In campaign documents filed with the State Division of Elections, Rogers now lists a small Lauderdale Lakes condominium in District 95 as her address. Broward Property Appraiser records confirm Rogers owns a 944-square foot condominium built around 1970. Although Rogers and her husband still own a house that is much nicer and more than twice the size of the 944-square-foot condominium, Rogers claims she meets the Florida Constitution’s residency requirements, insisting she uses the small condominium as her primary residence.

In March 2014, the Florida Legislature and Governor Rick Scott took steps to end this residency game. Joint Rule 7 of the Joint Rules of the Florida Legislature Resolution states,” A member shall be a legal resident and elector of his or her district at the time of election and shall maintain his or her legal residence within that district for the duration of his or her term of office. While a member may have multiple residences, he or she shall have only one legal residence. The legal residence of a member at a designated location is demonstrated by a totality of the circumstances.”

The Joint Resolution lists several factors to determine legal residence. These include the “abandonment of a prior legal residence” by selling that residence or giving up “rights and privileges” regarding the other residence. Other factors include voter registration records, bank records, homestead tax exemptions, and receipt of mail. The location of a legislator’s spouse and minor children can also be a factor.

Each lawmaker will be required to affirm, in writing, that he or she resides within the district. If evidence shows a lawmaker does not reside within the district, the legislature, acting as the sole judge in residency matters, will determine a vacancy has occurred.

Valies currently resides in House District 97, represented by Democrat Jared Moskowitz. According to the Broward County Property Appraiser (BCPA), Valies has owned a spacious Sunrise townhome since 1998. Valies receives the full Homestead tax exemption at this address.

BCPA records show Valies has owned a much smaller Lauderhill condominium since 2003.

While her official campaign documents filed with the State of Florida show a Tamarac address, voter registration websites show Valies is still registered to vote at her Sunrise home.

Corporate documents Valies filed with the State also use her Sunrise address.

Federal campaign records from 2012 and 2014 show Valies made contributions to the Obama Victory Fund and the Democrat Executive Committee of Florida. These contributions list Valies address in Sunrise.

Of course, Valies simply needs to reside in District 95 on the day of her election. Will she actually move into her small condo?

Or will she play the residency games perfected by Hazelle Rogers?

After all, Valies was recently an official with the Lauderhill Regional Chamber Of Commerce. Even though she lives in Sunrise.