While a diverse cross-section of Fort Lauderdale residents and business owners joined forces to oppose the sixteen story project dubbed “Trantalis Tower,” proponents of the affordable housing project by the AIDS Healthcare Foundation (AHF) appear to employees of AHF and members of a progressive group of young Democrats. On Monday evening, Fort Lauderdale Commissioner Ben Sorensen hosted a meeting to discuss the AHF/Healthy Housing Foundation plan to build 680 micro unit apartments in Fort Lauderdale. In early December, Michael Weinstein, the controversial CEO of AHF, held a disastrous press conference in Fort Lauderdale. Weinstein refused to answer questions from the media after accusing residents of the nearby Rio Vista neighborhood of making bigoted remarks. Weinstein’s performance caused local leaders like Mayor Dean Trantalis withhold their support of the project.
Monday night’s meeting was AHF’s latest attempts at damage control. Last week, a local supporter of the project announced a candlelight vigil would be held before the meeting. In her email, Robin Haines Merrill mischaracterized opposition to the project. Like Weinstein, she tried to paint local residents as villains. Merrill wrote, “Unfortunately there is unexpected resistance to this marvelous project. It comes from local business owners and some neighbors who feel that their property values will be affected, or that poor people are criminals that they don’t want in their neighborhood. A very strong campaign has been mounted to stop this affordable housing project.”
Attendees were told they would receive t-shirts for the vigil at Fort Lauderdale City Hall.
Instead of an outpouring of grassroots support, AHF loaded up two buses with employees of AHF, members of affiliated groups and even young Democrat Party leaders. Two black Volvo buses drove about 100 people from the AHF offices to City Hall. The low energy group was made up of AHF employees, leaders from Sunserve, individuals from People Helping People, a girls dance team and even the AHF project architect. The vigil was nothing more than a made-for-local-television event orchestrated by AHF legislative affairs director Ebonni Bryant.
Ms. Bryant passed out shirts and signs to the protestors. She delivered AHF talking points to local television reporters. In a post-meeting Facebook message, Bryant thanked several fellow members of the New Leaders Council (NLC) for their support.
According to their website, New Leaders Council (NLC) is “the hub for progressive Millennial thought leadership.” The group claims its training program “equips our leaders with the skills to run for office, manage campaigns, create start-ups and networks of thought leaders. NLC leaders take their activism back into their communities and workplaces to impact progressive change.”
Stephanie Rosendorf, another NLC alumnus, helped spread word of Monday’s vigil by sharing Robin Haines Merrill’s e-mail. Rosendorf is the aide for Broward County Commissioner Nan Rich. Commissioner Rich attended the June AHF press conference announcing the tower project.
Why is a Broward County Commission aide using her official County email address to promote an event in support of a private real estate development?
According to the NLC website, Chadwick Maxey is the director of the NLC Broward chapter. Maxey, a senior property manger with Diversified Realty Development, spoke at Monday’s meeting. Maxey said he was troubled by the lack of affordable housing south of the New River. He gave alleged information on rental properties from the Apartments.com website. Even though he never revealed his affiliation with NLC, Maxey sat with Ebonni Bryant and other NLC members at the meeting.
In January 2018, Maxey ran for the Fort Lauderdale Commission seat currently held by Steve Glassman. Maxey received two campaign contributions from Jason King, the former AHF lobbyist/legislative affairs director. In an interview with the Sun-Sentinel, Mayor Dean Trantalis called King his “plus 1” and said King introduced him to AHF CEO Michael Weinstein.
If “Trantalis Tower” is such a philanthropic endeavor, why did Michael Weinstein declare war on Rio Vista residents?
Why do AHF supporters continue to make false claims about the opposition to the project?
Why is anyone opposed to a private housing project a bigot or racist?
Why did “supporters” need bus rides and free dinners to come to city hall?
Why are local progressive activists running the AHF initiative like a political campaign with shills and earned media?
Is this really about helping Fort Lauderdale residents or is it all about taking “activism back into their communities and workplaces to impact progressive change?”
During its 2018 campaign against California rent-control laws, AIDS Healthcare Foundation (AHF) highlighted the “local resistance” of several Los Angeles neighborhoods against gentrification. Videos by left-wing activists from the Boyle Heights, Little Tokyo and Leimert Park neighborhoods were posted on the AHF/ Healthy Housing Foundation YouTube channel. These activists blasted developers who dared to buy property in their long established neighborhoods.
“URBAN COLONIAL CAPITALISM”
In the first video, left-wing activists describe their efforts to stop an art gallery complex from being built in the predominantly Mexican-American Boyle Heights neighborhood. The activists describe the neighborhood as their “cultural home.” They say it’s a “space of resistance” to preserve their “working class” roots. One activist claims rich outsiders want to gentrify Boyle Heights by using an art gallery to raise property values. According to this activist, gentrification is a “new form of urban colonial capitalism.” Another activist claims her “culture [is] being robbed from me.” Both activists vow to “fight to the end.”
“ETHNIC CLEANSING”
In the second video, the AHF/Healthy Housing Foundation visits with activists in the Little Tokyo neighborhood of Los Angeles. One activist describes how property in her “cultural center” is being “bought up by different cultures.” Another activist claims “collusion” between developers, “Big Capital” and local government to displace Japanese-Americans. He claims, “we’re the last of the Japanese-Americans!” To this activist, gentrification is “ethnic cleansing” and property developers are “perpetrators.” The activists vow to “build a massive political movement.”
“CULTURAL ERASURE/URBAN CLEANSING”
In the final video, a left-wing activist talks about his efforts to stop a shopping mall from being built in the predominantly African-American neighborhood of Leimert Park in Los Angeles. Once again, the AHF/Healthy Housing Foundation highlights the demonization of real estate developers. The activists claims the Leimert Park “gentrification is basically cultural erasure, urban cleansing, a reduction of people and land into dollar signs.” The activist claims the “perpetrators of gentrification” are not limited to “global capitalists.” This activist even attacks “flippers looking to make a buck.” He says, “there is a target on every tenant” in Leimert Park.
HYPOCRITES?
Last month, REDBROWARD revealed the communist past of AHF CEO Michael Weinstein. In the 1960s, a fourteen years old Michael Weinstein joined a “group of activists occupying” a New York high-rise development to protest the gentrification of their Brooklyn neighborhoods. According to an April 2017 exposé in the New York Times Magazine, Michael Weinstein’s an “ex-Trotskyite” who founded one of California’s first gay communist organizations. After his move to Los Angeles in 1972, Weinstein started the “Lavender And Red Union.” In 1977, a socialist newspaper reported the Lavender And Red Union, “a self-proclaimed “communist’ gay liberation group…recently embarked upon a cautious ideological turn toward Trotskyism.” The socialist paper said the group’s call for a “permanent revolution” was “a clear break with the Stalinist/Maoist/New Left milieu from which we emerged.”
Weinstein went on to become an editor for “Young Spartacus,” the official newspaper of the Communist Spartacist League. Throughout the late 1970s and early 1980s, Young Spartacus produced the typical pro-Communist screeds. Headlines of the Young Spartacus blasted US attempts to undermine the Soviet Union or Iran’s Ayatollah Khomeini, while other stories praised unions and left-wing political groups.
Fifty years later, Michael Weinstein and his Healthy Housing Foundation declared war on gentrification in California. His Prop 10 initiative to modernize rent control measures was defeated by California voters. Weinstein blamed the defeat on being outspent by real estate interests and developers.
So Weinstein set his sights on building a sixteen-story tower filled with nearly 700 “micro units” on land owned by AHF in Fort Lauderdale.
During a December press conference at AHF headquarters in Fort Lauderdale, Weinstein tried to blunt growing opposition to his pet project. The press conference was a public relations disaster. Weinstein attacked residents and the media for daring to ask him to verify aspects of his proposal.
Instead of compromise, Weinstein declared war on the residents of Fort Lauderdale and the media. He said, “We are as capable of waging a fight as anyone because People living with AIDS have face more discrimination and more hate than any other group.”
When asked about putting the project in a less residential area, Weinstein said, “Further from Rio Vista, is that what you’re saying? Further from the wealthy communities?”
Weinstein filled his remarks with the political language of an experienced communist newspaper editor. He said, “Will Fort Lauderdale…and these other communities of great wealth, continue to be places that are hospitable to people of low income or will these cities become, in essence, rich ghettos.”
Weinstein promised to maintain his opposition to development in Los Angeles. He said, “We have been against granting exemptions to luxury development in working class areas.”
Weinstein mocked residents who opposed his project because, “I see cranes everywhere. If the drawbridge goes up as soon as it involves poor people, it doesn’t speak well for the community.” He said, “Why is the luxury building going up? I see them everywhere.”
Weinstein tried to paint the opposition as bigots. He repeatedly said residents referred to not wanting “those people” living nearby. Weinstein refused to give specifics.
So why does Michael Weinstein support attacks on the rights of California property owners to develop their land in working class neighborhoods?
Weinstein’s Healthy Housing Foundation proudly boasted of the support it received from a “broad coalition” of fringe groups like the Democratic Socialists Of America while demonizing developers like the Blackstone Group.
Last month, Weinstein joined Sen. Bernie Sanders at The Sanders Institute Gathering to discuss his “radical” plans to change Fort Lauderdale, Los Angeles and other U.S. cities. Once again, Michael Weinstein’s ideas were filled with the coded language favored by the far-left activists featured in the AHF/Healthy Housing Foundation videos.
Michael Weinstein proposed putting micro houses (aka granny units) in everyone’s backyard. “Our nation is filled with backyards,” he said.
He called for the end of “speculative building” as well as a “crackdown on AirBnB that’s taken away a lot of housing stock.”
Weinstein said we must secure “housing for Americans” and not foreign investors “who are moving their money from one despotic country.”
Weinstein admitted this “sounds radical but it’s doable.”
Is Michael Weinstein proposing his own left-wing version of gentrification in Fort Lauderdale? He attacks “rich ghettos” like the Rio Vista neighborhoods of Fort Lauderdale. Does Weinstein believe they have no right to launch a “local resistance” like the residents of Boyle Heights, Little Tokyo and Leimert Park?
Michael Weinstein lives in California but he supports attacks on “foreign” property owners and developers from “outside cultures.” Isn’t Michael Weinstein the outsider in this local issue? How does he know what Fort Lauderdale residents want? At his press conference, Weinstein admitted his view of Fort Lauderdale residents was shaped by election night coverage of Florida elections.
Local government types and elected officials are backing off of their support of the massive AHF project. But, why did they support it in the first place? A simple Google search reveals Michael Weinstein’s ideology and political goals. Do our elected officials perform any due diligence before meeting with investors or developers?
“Any community would welcome someone who would want to help with affordable housing and homelessness,” Trantalis said, “but nobody really felt this was going to be the final outcome.”
Mayor Dean Trantalis,(second from right), joined former AHF lobbyist Jason King (second from left) at a November 2018 white party in Miami
Why would the Greater Fort Lauderdale Alliance support the AHF project. According to its website, taxpayer-supported Alliance is a coalition of business and community leaders which acts as the “primary economic development organization for Greater Fort Lauderdale/Broward County, the Greater Fort Lauderdale Alliance focuses on creating, attracting, expanding and retaining high-wage jobs and capital investment in high value targeted industries, developing more vibrant communities, and improving the quality of life for our area’s citizens.” Did the Alliance do any research before lending its name to the AHF project? When Weinstein announced the project last June, the Alliance logo was prominently featured on a banner behind him. Didn’t anyone Google the developments Weinstein and Healthy Housing Foundation were starting in California? Does the Greater Fort Lauderdale support rent-control in Broward County? Does the Alliance agree with Weinstein’s attacks on foreign ownership of local property? If so, that might come as a surprise to our friends from Canada and South America. What about Weinstein’s plan to use private backyards to house the homeless and senior citizens? Does the Alliance back putting these “micro houses” in Victoria Park or Coral Ridge neighborhoods? Does the Alliance share Weinstein’s opposition to AirBnB and similar groups operating in Broward County?
On Thursday, the Alliance also backed away from its support of Weinstein’s “Trantalis Tower.” According to the Sun-Sentinel, “Bob Swindell, president of the Greater Fort Lauderdale Alliance, which was listed in an AHF email as a supporter, said he was ‘deeply disappointed in the lack of receptivity shown by AHF in building a strong base of local support.'”
Why didn’t Mr. Swindell or Mayor Trantalis speak to local residents before giving their support to Michael Weinstein of California? Why did it take Weinstein’s declaration of war on Fort Lauderdale residents to get these men to act?
Broward residents deserve answers, right?
Bob Swindell Of The Greater Fort Lauderdale at the June 2018 AHF press conference
AHF CEO Michael Weinstein speaking at the June 2018 press conference
Websites store cookies to enhance functionality and personalise your experience. You can manage your preferences, but blocking some cookies may impact site performance and services.
Essential cookies enable basic functions and are necessary for the proper function of the website.
Name
Description
Duration
Cookie Preferences
This cookie is used to store the user's cookie consent preferences.